03 Feb Beware of unnecessary complexity
Image by wal_172619_II from Pixabay
Generally speaking, investors face two choices: being a part-owner of businesses around the world (stocks) or lending money to companies and governments (bonds). Funds are simply combinations of stocks and/or bonds in a mix that meets the mandate of the respective fund.
There is a finite number of listed stocks and available bonds, yet, interestingly, there are more stock market funds than there are stocks themselves! The investment industry is increasingly competitive and the number of funds available continues to rise. It is evident that having a sensible process for selecting which funds to include in an investor’s portfolio is key to investment success.
Cutting through the complexity and noise is a task that our firm’s Investment Research Committee (IRC) does not take lightly. A comprehensive whole-of-market fund screening process takes place on a regular basis. This process ensures that we remain confident that the funds recommended are ‘best-in-class’, offering the best chance of a successful investing experience.
Some investors assume that more funds must be better. Managing the risk exposure of a portfolio with 20 or more funds can be challenging for any investor. It can feel reassuring, as if adding extra funds automatically deepens diversification. The reality, however, is that the underlying stocks and bonds within the funds held are what provide the returns (and risk) to investors; therefore, holding multiple funds may simply adjust the weights of what is already held, or even double up on exactly the same stock and bond exposures[1].
This may be intentional and additive, but it can also create unnecessary complexity and duplication. Take, for example, two funds capturing the returns of US stock markets. Some may naively hold both, assuming that diversification improves, though if one offers better alignment with one’s goals (e.g., lower cost, longer track record, closer alignment with performance parameters), then it raises the question of why this is not selected alone.
Figure 1: Largest five holdings of two US stock market index tracking funds

Source: Fidelity Index US Fund (left), Legal & General US Index Trust (right). For example purposes only. Not a recommendation.
Clearly, splitting an allocation between both funds adds little to no value to investing outcomes, as the holdings are virtually the same.
Sometimes, holding several funds can be additive in some circumstances. For example, an investor looking to capture the returns of small-cap or value companies, in order to increase expected returns, might do so with a few funds that adjust the weights to underlying stocks to provide a ‘tilted’ exposure to these desired attributes.
Figure 2: Largest five holdings of US stock market index tracking fund, and small cap value fund

Source: Fidelity Index US Fund (left), SPDR MSCI USA Small Cap Val (right). For example purposes only. Not a recommendation.
Investors seeking a sensibly structured long-term portfolio do not need to own an unnecessary number of funds to do so. Simplicity does not mean a lack of sophistication. Choosing the best funds for their designated role and monitoring them regularly through time is key to investing success. This responsibility sits within the remit of our IRC and forms part of the regular review process of the investment solution we recommend.
Beware of unnecessary complexity, disguised as diversification.
Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler
Albert Einstein
With investing your capital is at risk.
Important notice: This marketing communication is for information purposes only. Unless indicated, all views expressed in this document are those of the author(s). The information in this document does not constitute advice or a recommendation and you should not make any investment decisions on the basis of it.
[1] Note that investor assets sit in a ringfenced custodial account, not on a fund manager’s balance sheet. Splitting allocations between managers on this basis should not be a concern, ceteris paribus.